During the past 3 months, we have been very busy modifying our website, participating in family obligations, and recovering from a 6-week illness.
As a result, we have not had time to devote to preparing our planned April 2009 Bimonthly Article featuring a "Look back at the Powerball Lotteries Recent Changes". We continue to plan on writing this article and will publish it in June 2009. Looking at how the Annuity Jackpot and Implied Yields have risen in the past week or so, we believe this will be an informative article.
Following that issue, we will present an: "Analysis of Hot/Cold Lottery Numbers" in August 2009.
We look forward to completing these Posts in the upcoming months and your continued readership.
JL..........
A collection of lottery articles analyzing specific aspects of Mega Millions, Powerball, Lotto Max, Lotto 649, Euromillions, and other lottery games. Examples of topics include advice on: when to buy and play guides; rule and format changes; benefits of buying the Megaplier, Powerplay, Sizzler options; how much money the lottery keeps; cash verses annuity analysis; implied yields; lottery odds of single and multiple tickets; etc. Includes annuity and multi-ticket calculator gadgets for your use.
Monday, May 11, 2009
April 2009 Bimonthly Postponed
Tuesday, April 14, 2009
March Entrecard Droppers
The following is the list of our Top Entrecard Visitors during the month of March 2009.
Mar Top 10
| * | A Simple Life | 31 |
| * * * | Mommy's Little Corner | 31 |
| * | Life's sweets and spices | 31 |
| * * * * | BMWF1Blog | 31 |
| The Modern Mom | 31 | |
| moms..... check nyo | 31 | |
| Kids Toys | 30 | |
| Traders' Hub | 29 | |
| * * | Anything Goes W/ Pahn | 29 |
| * | Warcraft Blog | 28 |
Note: The red asterisk indicates the number of
continuous months
this visitor was one of our Top Droppers
continuous months
this visitor was one of our Top Droppers
Besides the above, we wish to
Thank All of You
for dropping in on us!
Thank All of You
for dropping in on us!
Tuesday, March 17, 2009
February Entrecard Droppers
The following is the list of our Top Entrecard Visitors during the month of February 2009.
Feb Top 10
| * * * | My note's | 31 |
| Warcraft Blog | 31 | |
| Life's A Pizza Pie | 31 | |
| | A Simple Life | 31 |
| * * | Mommy's Little Corner | 31 |
| * | Anything Goes W/ Pahn | 31 |
| Life's sweets and spices | 31 | |
| * * * | BMWF1Blog | 31 |
| Bingo Sites Online for Women | 31 | |
| * | my review | 31 |
Note: The red asterisk indicates the number of
continuous months
this visitor was one of our Top Droppers
continuous months
this visitor was one of our Top Droppers
Besides the above, we wish to
Thank All of You
for your continued support!
Thank All of You
for your continued support!
Friday, February 27, 2009
3 UK Lotto Oddities or Questioning Camelot
We first began offering Lottery Power Picks to players of the UK Lotto in the beginning of January 2008. Since that time, we are astonished at the frequency of Jackpot winnings and how many winners are reported per drawing. So, we decided to investigate this topic to determine whether this is or could be true. In a world where extensive financial fraud is being discovered and shaking our global economies, we believe this is the time to determine whether the reporting of the UK Lotto results are:
Too Good to be True?
As being reported on the radio and televisions, investors and regulators often failed to be reasonable or cautious when seeing an opportunity. Would we call this Greed?
Inflating the winning results of Lottery Drawings gives the impression that "everyone can win". Like the investors who have fallen for recent Ponzi Schemes, both UK and global residents may foolishly believe that they too can win, and will fall victim to ficticious reporting. In this scenerio, innocent people, not only the greedy, can easily be trapped into investing into something they believe is truthful.
What We Found Were
3 Distinct Oddities
concerning
the UK Lotto.
3 Distinct Oddities
concerning
the UK Lotto.
This is the disturbing summary of our findings.
The Facts
After each drawing, we record the winning numbers, prizes, number of winners and locations provided by the Official Lottery Websites.
Having reviewed and summarized this is information for the past 4 years, we find that the UK Lotto has averaged 81.75 winning drawings per year (out of 104-105) and that the number of winners reported on the UK Lotto Website each has increased each year, from 181 in 2005, 203 in 2006, 226 in 2007, to 246 in 2008 (see MerseyWorld). This represents a yearly average of 214 winners per year, or approximately 2.05 winners in each winning drawing. In addition, there have also been drawings with multiple winning tickets reported, the highest being 12 on one date. Combining the 6 eights, 2 nines, 4 tens, 2 elevens, and 1 twelve, there were 15 winning drawings that had 8 or more winners. This seems rather high.
By comparison, the Canadian Lotto 649 has averaged about 48 winning drawings per year during the past 4 years. The number of those winners reported were: 63 in 2005, 73 in 2006, 69 in 2007, to 63 in 2008. For 649, the 4 year average was 67, around 1.4 in each winning drawing. Like the UK Lotto, there have also been drawings with multiple winning tickets reported, with highest being 5 on one occasion, and a few fours. Most duplicates were 2 or 3 tickets.
Because the frequency of winners as well as the number of winners in the UK Lotto seems proportionally too large, we will examine additional information such as:
- How many UK Lottery Tickets are sold
- Population sizes of the United Kingdom
- Camelot reportings of winners.
The UK Lotto Background
The UK Lotto is part of the National Lottery, with drawings twice a week, on Wednesday and Saturday. It is a 649 game, meaning players pick 6 numbers from 1 to 49 which they hope will match the numbers drawn. The game tickets costs £1 each.
In order to win a prize, the player's numbers must match 3, 4, 5, or all 6 of those drawn. An additional bonus ball is also drawn, but it only counts if the player matchs 5 of the 6 numbers.
Camelot
Since 1994, all lotteries operated in the UK is licensed to Camelot, who was recently awarded a 10-year extension to operate the lottery National Lottery from 2009 to 2019.
Besides operating the lottery, Camelot is responsible for reporting both their lottery drawing and financial results to the UK Government and the public.
When reporting the lottery drawing results for each game, Camelot indicates the numbers drawn, the total amount of the jackpot, the number of winners, and the estimated jackpot for the next drawing. What it does not tell us is:
- If the number of winners reported is the actual number of single tickets sold, or
- If it is the total number of people who have a family or some other relationship with the ticket holder,
- And where the winning tickets were sold.
Semi-annual proceeds ending September 27 2008 (April-September) was £2,559.7m which consisted of £1,974.5m from draw based games (Lotto, EuroMillions, Thunderball, etc).
Oddity #1: Underpayment to Good Causes
Camelot Proceeds Distribution
From various locations in the UK Lotto site and the individual Press Releases, we are informed that Camelot distributes the lottery money it receives as follows:
- 5% of revenue taken for operating costs
- 28% for Good Causes
- 12% paid as lottery duty to the government
- 50% returned to players in for form of cash payments
- 5% paid to retailer vendors.
- £1,351.8m to Good Causes for the year from April 1 2007 - March 31 2008, and
- £689.2m to Good Causes for the 6 months of April 1 2008 - September 2008
- £4,966.3m * 28% = 1,390.6 ( yearly)
- £2,559.7m * 28% = 716.7 ( 6 months )
- £38.8m more for the 2007-2008 year, meaning that only 27.2% was paid, not 28%, and
- £27.5m more for the past 6 months, or 26.9% was paid, again not 28%.
So where's the missing money?
Who knows?
Who knows?
We believe that £66.3m is a lot of money. The citizens of the United Kingdom should not be short-changed.
Oddity #2: Inflating Number of Winners
What about the Winners?
Turning our attention to the number of winners reported, we have listed two drawing examples where the National Lottery reported multiple winners, when in fact, the Camelot Press Releases indicated that there was only one winning ticket sold.
Example 1: In the Nov 15 2008 Drawing Lottery Results, Camelot reports that there were 2 winners who received £2,630,225 each. However, the National Lotto Press Release titled Stoke City Fans Score Lotto Jackpot Win describe the husband and wife who together won the £5,260,450 jackpot with one ticket. So in reality, there were not 2 winning tickets as stated, but only one.
Example 2: The National Lottery reports that there were 2 winners in the Nov 19 2008 Lotto drawing and that each received £1,017,166. However, the Camelot Press Release Students Scoop Millionaire Status tell of a young couple who "buy one single Lotto every week". The pair indeed had the single winning lottery ticket which paid a £2,034,332 Jackpot Prize. So while 2 individuals split the winnings, there was only one winning ticket, not two.
But not all individuals are featured by either Camelot or the National Lottery. Take for instance the two drawings:
- 12/20/2008 - 10 winners reported
- 10/11/2008 - 11 winners reported
Sometimes the National Lottery does not inflate the number of winning tickets. For example, the Winners Gallery features two winners for the 15th November 2008 drawing. One ticket holder is identified as the "Suffolk Lads and Lasses" and the second as Jackie and John Livesley". In this case, the National Lottery's Prize Breakdown for this drawing correctly lists the number of winners as two.
So what can we conclude about the reporting of winners when looking at the National Lottery results?
Basically, all we know is
that at least one winning ticket
was sold, that's it!
that at least one winning ticket
was sold, that's it!
From the information reported, there is no way for the public to know how many winning tickets were indeed sold.
And What about the Frequency of Jackpot Winners?
From our Lottery Power Picks site, we find that during the 4 years 2005-2008, the jackpot has been won in 327 of the 417 drawings held, which is 78.4% of the time.
By comparison, the Canadian Lotto 649 has been won in 192 drawings of the 417 held. This equates to 46.0% of the time.
By simply looking at the two percentages, one would think that the UK Lotto is won too often.
But, after researching certain statistics, we believe that these numbers are reasonable that that there is probably no manipulation in the UK Lotto.
We can rationalize the frequency of winners by comparing the differences between the Canadian and UK Lottos, where:
- the UK Population is 60,943,912 (July 2008 est.)
- and each UK Lotto ticket costs £1
- the Canadian Population is 33,212,696 (July 2008 est.)
- and each Canadian Lotto 649 ticket costs C$2.
We would expect
the winning Jackpot combination
to be sold more often in the UK
than in Canada.
the winning Jackpot combination
to be sold more often in the UK
than in Canada.
Since this is indeed the case, we believe that Camelot reports the existence of a winning correctly.
Looking at Average UK Lotto Sales
Since each UK ticket costs £1, the number of tickets sold and the amount of money received is identical. Thus, summarizing the estimated amounts of ticket sales provided on the MerseyWorld UK Lotto website, we learn the average number of tickets sold for:
- Saturday drawings is £35.5m (for 2008: £33.7m; 2007: £33.7m, 2006: £36.2m; and 2005: £38.3m).
- Wednesday drawings is £19.4m (for 2008: £18.6m; 2007: £18.6m, 2006: £19.3m; and 2005: £21.0m).
What's important here is that the average sales for both the Saturday and Wednesday drawings exceed the absolute number of possible combinations, which is 13,983,816. For Saturdays, more than 2.5 times the number of combinations is played. On Wednesdays, slightly less than 1.4 times the combinations are played.
Since all ticket sales exceed the available combinations, one would think that the winning combination would always be sold. But, this is not the case. Of the 52 available Saturdays drawings each year, there are 6 to 7 drawings which produce no winner. For Wednesday, approximately 22 drawings fail to produce a winner. This means that "a lot of duplicate tickets" are sold.
While we don't have the information available, it would be interesting to know the breakdown between player and quick-pick selected numbers.
Oddity #3: Underfunding Jackpots
Prize Allocation Oddity
The allocation of monies paid into to the players fund is also ambiguous. The National Lottery page How are the Prizes Calculated states that "at least 45% of the draw sales are allocated to the Prize Fund", and that "52% of the Pools Fund" is allocated to the Match 6 main numbers. Using these percenatages, we find that:
- For average Saturday sales of £35.5m, £8.3 million would be allocated to the Match 6 prize.
- For average Wednesday sales of £19.4m, £4.5 million would be allocated to the Match 6 prize.
- And, for the combined drawing average sales of £27.5m, £6.4 million would be allocated to the Match 6 prize.
For the past 4 years,
the average Jackpot was only £5.0 million.
This is £1.4 million less per drawing
than advertised by the rules!
the average Jackpot was only £5.0 million.
This is £1.4 million less per drawing
than advertised by the rules!
To further confuse the allocation, Camelot's Earnings Reports state that: "50% returned to players in for form of cash payments". Assuming that 52% of this amount is still allocated to the Jackpot price of Match 6, we calculate that: £9.2m is paid back on Saturdays; £5.0m on Wednesdays; and £7.1 paid on the average combined drawings.
So, Who Should We Believe?
Camelot or the National Lottery?
Camelot or the National Lottery?
These questions are hard to answer since they are both one in the same, and neither agrees with itself.
In either case, we believe that
Camelot failed to pay back
the players approximately
£146 million per year!
Camelot failed to pay back
the players approximately
£146 million per year!
Why do We Care?
Concluding Remarks
There are several reasons that we care about the misrepresentations stated by Camelot regarding the UK Lotto. We believe that:
- Governmental operators of all lotteries should properly and accurately disclose the conditions and distributions of the lottery proceeds.
- There should be no false advertising.
- Failure to fund or pay stated distributions, whether it be to the players or the Good Causes, is criminal.
- Inflating the number of winning tickets is not only misleading, but presents the pretext of Fraud. Players are given a false sense of opportunity when one does not exist.
And, to Legislatures in the United States who are considering Privatizing their State Lotteries, we urge them to take a close look at the risks of Licensing their operations. There is a lot of money at stake, and we cannot simply "Trust" that the operator is doing the right thing. Monitoring these operations should be continuous and would be very expensive venture!
Learn More
To learn more about this subject, visit and explore the official sites from which we extracted much of our data.
Monday, February 16, 2009
January Entrecard Droppers
The following is the list of our Top Entrecard Visitors during the month of January 2009.
Jan Top 10
| * * | My note's | 31 |
| * | Gadget Spot | 31 |
| * | Mommy's Little Corner | 31 |
| Anything Goes W/ Pahn | 31 | |
| Retro Yakking | 31 | |
| * * | BMWF1Blog | 31 |
| my review | 31 | |
| Basketball Daily | 31 | |
| * | moms..... check nyo | 31 |
| * | iWalk,U2? | 30 |
Note: The red asterisk indicates the number of previous months
this visitor was a Top Dropper.
this visitor was a Top Dropper.
Thank-you all once again!
Tuesday, January 13, 2009
December Entrecard Droppers
We wish to thank all of our dedicated daily visitors and readers. In particular, we especially honor our Top 10 Entrecard droppers during the month of December 2008:
December EC Dropper Awards
Thanks again!
Wednesday, December 31, 2008
How 2009 Powerball Changes Effect You
In August 2008, the MUSL announced that the State of Florida would be joining the Powerball lottery. With the increased population of new players, Powerball expanded the set of white ball numbers and decreased the number of red Powerballs, in order to make the game more attractive. The minimum jackpot will be increased, and for those who purchase the Power Play Option, the second prize of matching all 5 white balls will be fixed at $1 million.
Tickets for the new Powerball format will go on sale on Sunday January 4, 2009, and the first drawing will be held on Wednesday January 7, 2009.
While players should be excited about these new changes, they should understand that this new format:
Benefits the Powerball States
Not the Players!
Not the Players!
Summary of Publicized Changes
First, lets review the Powerball changes that will become effective in January.
- White Balls increased from 55 to 59
- Red Powerballs decreased from 42 to 39
- Minimum annuity jackpot increased from $15 to $20 Million
- Powerplay Match 5 multiplier (5+0) fixed at 5X, payable in $1 million cash
- Chances of winning the jackpot increased to 195.2 million
- Overall odds of winning any prize decreased to 35.1
- Jackpot pool percentage increased from 30.3% to 32.5%.
Combination Changes
Table PB09-1 summarizes combinatorial changes implied by the changes in the quantity of white and red balls. As shown, the Powerballs decrease from 42 to 39 balls, a 7.1 decrease. At the same time, the white balls increase from 55 to 59, a 7.3% increase. This appears to be a net wash.
However, the number of white ball combinations has increased from 3.5 million to 5.0 million, which is a 43.9% increase. But because the Powerballs decreased, the total number of all 6 number combinations increased only by 49 million, or 33.6%.
| Table PB09-1: Combination Changes | |||||
| Item | New Matrix | Old Matrix | Change | Pct Change | Dir |
| Tot Combos | 195,249,054 | 146,107,962 | 49,141,092 | 33.6% | ↑ |
| Powerballs | 39 | 42 | -3 | -7.1% | ↓ |
| White Balls | 59 | 55 | 4 | 7.3% | ↑ |
| 5-Number Combos | 5,006,386 | 3,478,761 | 1,527,625 | 43.9% | ↑ |
Winners Changes
Since the winning prize structure remains the same, the new format will produce more individual winners. While the number of combinations increased by 33.6%, the total number of winners increases by 39.3%. This is a 6.0% advantage for the players.
At the same time, the number of losers increases by 33.5%, about the same as the increase in combinations.
Further, the overall chances of winning any prize decrease from 36.6 to 35.1, which is 4.1% advantage for the players. This is reinforced by the fact that the percent of winners also increases by 4.4%.
| Table PB09-2: Winners Chances | |||||
| Item | New Matrix | Old Matrix | Change | Pct Change | Dir |
| Tot Winners | 5,560,464 | 3,991,302 | 1,569,162 | 39.3% | ↑ |
| Tot Losers | 189,688,590 | 142,116,660 | 47,571,930 | 33.5% | ↑ |
| Overall Chances | 35.11 | 36.61 | -1.50 | -4.1% | ↓ |
| Pct Winners | 2.85% | 2.73% | 0.12% | 4.4% | ↑ |
Thus far, it appears that players will benefit from the game format changes.
Payout Information
But reviewing the payout information presented in Table PB09-3 below, one can begin to understand why the players do not really benefit. In the new format, $54.1 million will be returned to the players. This is only a 23.5% increase. Remembering that the total number of combinations increased by 33.6%, it becomes apparent that a full 10.1% of the new money raised remains within the Powerball organization. Since the number of combinations increased by 49.1 million and each combination represents a dollar, we quickly see that $4.9 million extra goes to Powerball, not the players.
This is reinforced by reviewing the Average Ticket Win, which at $9.73 (verses $10.97) is a 11.3% drop. Both of which re-iterate that players receive less money in the new game.
| Table PB09-3: Payout Info | |||||
| Item | New Matrix | Old Matrix | Change | Pct Change | Dir |
| Tot Payout | $54,112,290 | $43,800,030 | $10,312,260 | 23.5% | ↑ |
| Avg Tkt Win | $9.73 | $10.97 | -$1.24 | -11.3% | ↓ |
| Return per $ | $0.28 | $0.30 | -$0.02 | -6.7% | ↓ |
| Jackpot/Odds | $569,577 | $409,763 | $159,814 | 39.0% | ↑ |
| Jackpot Parity | $161,136,764 | $117,307,932 | $43,828,832 | 37.4% | ↑ |
Additionally, the Jackpot/Odds and Jackpot Parity percent changes of 39.0% and 37.4% indicate growth that exceeds the 33.6% increase in new combinations. Should the Minimum Jackpot be greater, these would be more in line, and help to benefit the player. But, since the Jackpot is fixed at $20 million, overall payouts to the players is minimized.
Power Play Jackpot Breakeven
Lastly, for completeness, the increase in combinations and payouts implies that the Power Play Jackpot Breakeven level is increased as well. From Table PB09-4, we learn that players should purchase the Power Play Option whenever the Jackpot is below $62.6 million. Above that level, players should always skip this option and go for the Jackpot itself by spending the additional dollar on an individual ticket.
Lastly, for completeness, the increase in combinations and payouts implies that the Power Play Jackpot Breakeven level is increased as well. From Table PB09-4, we learn that players should purchase the Power Play Option whenever the Jackpot is below $62.6 million. Above that level, players should always skip this option and go for the Jackpot itself by spending the additional dollar on an individual ticket.
| Table PB09-4: Power Play Breakeven | |||||
| Item | New Matrix | Old Matrix | Change | Pct Change | Dir |
| Tot Payout | $62,568,435 | $43,200,045 | $19,368,390 | 44.8% | ↑ |
Conclusion
While the new Powerball matrix format increases a players chance of winning a prize by increasing the number of winners, the amount of money returned back to the players is proportionately lower than the existing game. As we have seen, the average winning ticket will now be $9.73, which is 11.3% lower than present. Further, the actual percent of amount of money is 10% less than what has been increased.
Since nearly $5.0 million extra will be retained by Powerball, we believe the new format benefits the Lottery Organization rather than the players. To remain fair, either the minimum jackpot should have been set at $25 million, or lower tier prize payouts should have been increased.
In a year when lottery sales have declined, it is not surprising that the Powerball organizers revised the format in order to increase their retained profits.
While the lure of winning a minimum of $20 million is nothing to sneeze about, players should understand who profits and who loses.
We hope you have found this study to be informative.
Learn More
To learn more about this subject, visit our in-depth pages that provide the detailed numbers behind each of these options.
While the new Powerball matrix format increases a players chance of winning a prize by increasing the number of winners, the amount of money returned back to the players is proportionately lower than the existing game. As we have seen, the average winning ticket will now be $9.73, which is 11.3% lower than present. Further, the actual percent of amount of money is 10% less than what has been increased.
Since nearly $5.0 million extra will be retained by Powerball, we believe the new format benefits the Lottery Organization rather than the players. To remain fair, either the minimum jackpot should have been set at $25 million, or lower tier prize payouts should have been increased.
In a year when lottery sales have declined, it is not surprising that the Powerball organizers revised the format in order to increase their retained profits.
While the lure of winning a minimum of $20 million is nothing to sneeze about, players should understand who profits and who loses.
We hope you have found this study to be informative.
Learn More
To learn more about this subject, visit our in-depth pages that provide the detailed numbers behind each of these options.
Saturday, December 13, 2008
November Entrecard Droppers
Merry Christmas
&
Happy New Year
To all of our Readers.
&
Happy New Year
To all of our Readers.
With special thanks to our dedicated daily visitors, and especially our Top 10 Entrecard droppers in the month of November 2008:
November EC Dropper Awards
We hope your Holidays are Joyous.
Noel
Friday, November 14, 2008
Top Entrecard Droppers
We sincerely thank all of you who have visited and dropped on our site each day. In particular, we wish to publicize our Top 10 visitors:
In addition, we wish to thank everyone else who took the time to visit and drop on our site. We hope to continue seeing all of you every day possible.
October EC Dropper Awards
In addition, we wish to thank everyone else who took the time to visit and drop on our site. We hope to continue seeing all of you every day possible.
Thanks Again
Friday, October 31, 2008
Florida Lotto Plus Analysis. Should you buy the $2 or $3 Option?
The Florida Lottery enhanced the Florida Lotto by introducing the $2 and $3 LOTTO PLUS jackpot levels on March 2, 2008. This gives players of that game the option to "Super Size" their jackpot winnings. This means that rather than strictly buying a single $1 ticket, players can instead:
- Spend $2 per ticket, and increase the base jackpot payout by $10 Million if that combination wins; or
- Spend $3 per ticket, and increase the base jackpot payout by $25 Million if that combination wins.
The lure of increasing the size of the Jackpot purse for only $1 or $2 more seems to be very attractive on the surface. Thus, we asked ourselves two questions:
Would We Buy the Lotto Plus Option?
And, If so, Which One?
the Lotto Plus Option
in Certain Instances
but it would depend on the size of the Base Jackpot being offered. As for which one to buy, we found that:
The $3 Lotto Plus Option is the Best
(If You Can Afford It)
And, If so, Which One?
Our analysis found that:
Yes, We Would Buythe Lotto Plus Option
in Certain Instances
but it would depend on the size of the Base Jackpot being offered. As for which one to buy, we found that:
(If You Can Afford It)
How would you know when to buy the Florida Lotto Plus Option?
You should always buy the plus option whenever the current jackpot value is below its Jackpot Breakeven level.
- For $2 Lotto Plus, Breakeven is $5.8 million: Buy the $2 Lotto Plus Option whenever the Jackpot is below this value. Never above this. Buy 2 tickets instead.
- For $3 Lotto Plus, Breakeven is $8.3 million: Buy the $3 Lotto Plus Option whenever the Jackpot is below this value. Never above this. Buy 3 tickets instead.
The reason these levels can be calculated is because ONLY the Jackpot prize is increased for those winners who purchased the option. No other lower level prizes are increased. So, as the Jackpot increases above its minimum, only the probability weighted amount of jackpot money returned to players increases. At some point, which we call Jackpot Breakeven, the Single $1 Ticket jackpot return outweighs the increased Jackpot payments per dollar spent. Once this point is reached, buying the Lotto Plus option is not a good investment. Remember, because the option costs $1 or $2 more, it is necessary to divide these probability weighted returns by 2 or 3 before comparing them to single $1 tickets. When the jackpot is above the breakeven level, the per dollar return of Florida Lotto Plus tickets becomes less and less valuable compared to that of a regular $1 ticket.
As lottery players, we want to play the option that returns the most money back to us, the players. As you will see below, your option changes depending on the jackpot level.
Florida Lotto Plus
When a player buys the Florida Lotto Plus Option only the Jackpot will be increased. For the $2 option, jackpot payout increases by $10 Million. For the $3 option, jackpot payout increases by $25 Million.
However, the Florida Lotto has 22,957,480 unique combinations. Only one of these will be selected in any particular drawing. Excluding duplicates, there will be only 1 winning combination.
To play, the Florida Lotto requires a player to select 6 numbers from a set of 53 (there is no bonus ball). Prizes are only paid out to players who correctly match 3, 4, 5, or 6 of the numbers. This means that of the nearly 23 million combinations, only 340,798 will return any prize payout.
The graph below illustrates both the expected Lotto Plus $3 Return (in blue) and the Lotto Plus $2 Return (in red) against the expected return of a Single Ticket (in green).
When the advertised jackpot is set to the minimum $3 million, the $3 Lotto Plus returns the most money, $0.467 of each dollar received, back to the players. By comparison, the $2 Lotto Plus returns the $0.374 of each dollar received, and a Single $1 Ticket returns $0.313.
When the jackpot level reaches $5.8 million, the returns of the $2 Lotto Plus and a Single Ticket are equal, at $0.436 each. However, both of these are substantially below the $3 Lotto Plus's $0.508 return. (Note that above this breakeven level, the single ticket returns out pace that of the $2 option.)
When the advertised jackpot level reaches $8.3 million, the $3 Lotto Plus and a Single Ticket returns are equal, at $0.544 each. This jackpot level is the $3 Lotto Plus breakeven. From the graph, it is clear that either of these two scenarios are preferable to the $2 Lotto Plus option which only returns $0.490 per dollar spent.
Above the $3 Lotto Plus breakeven point, single tickets purchased without either option return more to the players. When the jackpot grows to $23 million, $1.184 is returned to single ticket holders, compared to only $0.810 for $2 Lotto Plus, and $0.758 for $3 Lotto Plus.
Players should purchase Lottery Tickets like they would any other investment, and always seek the highest return on their dollars. Thus, when the Florida Lotto jackpot is below $8.3 million, the $3 Lotto Plus should be purchased. Above $8.3 M, always buy single tickets. If you cannot afford the $3 option, you should consider the $2 Lotto Plus. In this case, breakeven is at $5.8 million. Buy the $2 option below this level, and single tickets above it.
Alternate Analysis
Since the only prize that is increased by $2 and $3 Lotto Plus is the actual Jackpot paid to winners, we can alternately analyze the jackpot payout on a per dollar basis. For this, a simple algebraic relationship is defined as:
JackpotAmount = (JackpotAmount + OptionPayout)/CostPerTicket
As seen, the OptionPayout and CostPerTicket variables are fixed but depend upon whether we are analyzing the $2 or $3 option. This means that we can solve for the optimal Jackpot amount for either of these options.
Solving for the $2 Lotto Option, our formula changes to: JackpotAmount = (JackpotAmount + 10)/2 which implies the $2 Plus JackpotAmount of $10 Million.
Similarily solving for the $3 Lotto Plus Option, our formula changes to: JackpotAmount = (JackpotAmount + 25)/3 which implies a $3 Plus JackpotAmount of $12.5 Million.
If you prefer this analysis to breakeven returns, we advise that you NEVER purchase either option when the base jackpot is above $12.5 million. At this level, go for the Jackpot, and purchase multiple combinations, giving yourself increased chances of winning.
Conclusion
To conclude, the decision to buy the Florida Lotto Plus option is dependent upon the jackpot size. When the jackpot is below its breakeven level, players are encouraged to buy the plus option. But, when the jackpot is above its breakeven level, players should forego this option, and buy 2 or 3 straight tickets instead (depending on whether you are considering the $2 or $3 option).
Our belief is that both of these options have value to the Florida Lottery player and should be considered.
Looking back at the May 10th 2008 $2 Lotto Plus winner, we believe the player made a very good choice, not only for his winnings, but because the base jackpot level was approximately equal to the $2 breakeven level of $5.8 million. Rounding this number to the nearest million, the player was indifferent to buying the option or not. Having purchased the option and having the winning combination, the player won a $16 million annuity jackpot, consisting of the $6 million base amount plus the $10 million option payout. Well done!
Learn More
To learn more about this subject, visit our in-depth pages that provide the detailed numbers behind each of these options.
- Florida Lotto Plus Analysis
- Florida Lotto Complete Odds & Return to Players
- How to Play the Florida Lotto
- Lotto Plus FAQs
- First $2 LOTTO PLUS™ Winner
Focus for December 2008: The New Powerball Changes, What They Mean to You
Friday, September 26, 2008
Chances of Duplicate Lottery Tickets - Special Edition
We've often wondered what the likelihood of different lottery players having the same combinations in a single drawing actually was. Looking for an answer, we searched the internet, but could not find it. So, we decided to conduct our own research. This was performed by studying the classic Identical Birthday Problem, identifying the underlying mathematical formula, applying this formula to individual lotteries, and summarizing our results.
Birthday Problem
How often have you been in a group of people and discovered that two of you shared the same birthday? Was this purely coincidence, a random event? Or, was it in fact highly likely?
The classic form of the Birthday Problem, which is familiar to most everyone, quantifies the chances of two people sharing the same birthday. Given a probability of certainty, the Birthday Problem solution calculates the size of smallest group necessary to meet that probability.
Thus, when in a group of 23 (22.5 actually) people, you can be 50% certain that two or more of you share the same birthday. To be 99.9% sure, you need a group of 71 people!
The Mathematics
The formula behind this solution is fairly simple, and in terms of Excel is written as:
SQRT(2*PopulationSize*LN(1/(1-Probability)))
We solve the Birthday Problem by substituting the PopulationSize with 365 days and the Probability of 0.50 or 0.999 to acheive the answers above.
Calculating the Chances of Duplicate Lottery Tickets
We applied the formula above to the various lottery games that we cover and produced the Chance of Duplicates Table below.
The first column identifies the lottery Game. Next is the Population (total number of possible combinations) for that game. The 3rd and 4th columns are our results. Column A identifies the minimum number of tickets that must be issued in order to be 50% sure that there at least one duplicate. Column B is similar, but identifies the minimum number of tickets that must be issued in order to be 99.9% sure that there at least one duplicate.
| Chance of Duplicates | |||
| Game | Population | Col A 50% Sure | Col B 99.9% Sure |
| Powerball | 146,107,962 | 14,232.0 | 44,928.3 |
| Powerball (Jan 09) | 195,249,054 | 16,452.1 | 51,937.1 |
| Mega Millions | 175,711,536 | 15,607.3 | 49,270.1 |
| Lotto 649 | 13,983,816 | 4,402.9 | 13,899.4 |
| Super 7 | 62,891,499 | 9,377.4 | 29,476.7 |
| Super Lotto Plus | 41,416,353 | 7,577.3 | 23,920.5 |
| Hot Lotto | 10,939,383 | 3,894.3 | 12,293.6 |
| EuroMillions | 76,275,360 | 10,283.0 | 32,462.0 |
| Irish Lotto | 8,145,060 | 3,360.3 | 10,607.9 |
| UK Lotto | 13,983,816 | 4,402.9 | 13,899.4 |
| Thunderball | 3,895,584 | 2,323.9 | 7,336.2 |
| Birthdays | 365 | 22.5 | 71.0 |
As shown, the chances that duplicate lottery tickets will be sold are very likely. For example, there is a 50% chance that duplicate Powerball tickets will be issued when only 14,232 tickets are sold. And, you can be 99.9% sure that there are duplicates when only 45,000 tickets are sold. When Powerball changes format in January 2009, the total number of possible combinations will increase by over 49 million. Even so, you can be 99.9% sure that there will be duplicates when only 52,000 tickets are sold. By reading the table above, you can determine the likelihood of duplicate tickets in your favorite lottery, whether it be: Powerball, Mega Millions, Super Lotto Plus, Hot Lotto, EuroMillions, Irish Lotto, UK Lotto, or Thunderball.
Summary
This study identifies the number of tickets that must be sold in order to be 50% and 99.9% mathematically certain that one or more people will have duplicate combinations. While this information is not sufficient to estimate the total number of duplicate tickets, it provides a guideline to understand the chances. If you live in a small town of around 50,000 people, and everyone buys 1 lottery ticket, don't be surprised if you discover that someone else has the same combination as yours.
JL .........
Labels:
education,
fun with math,
lottery,
lotto,
mathematics,
probabilities
Friday, August 29, 2008
MM Cash or Annuity? The LPP Analysis of the Mega Millions Jackpot
Mega Millions players are required to choose whether they wish to receive Cash or Annuity Option at the time of purchase. In most States, the players who choose the Annuity Option may opt to take the Cash Value within 60 days of winning, but those who originally chose the Cash Option may not change their mind. After asking around, we confirmed that most people select the Cash Option, believing this is the best choice. So, if you play Mega Millions, what do you choose:
The Cash or Annuity Option?
Since the beginning of 2002 through Aug 24 2008, seventy-five (75) jackpots have been won by individuals and groups. These are listed in the Mega Million Jackpot History of Winners page. However, the Mega Millions website does not indicate whether these winners had chosen the cash or annuity payouts. But, it does feature profiles of 19 winners in their Winners Gallery. Of these 19, three have chosen the Annuity, and the rest have taken the Cash Option.
This means that around 85%
of Mega Millions players
take the Cash Option.
Is this the best decision?
Or, would they have more money by taking the Annuity?
of Mega Millions players
take the Cash Option.
Is this the best decision?
Or, would they have more money by taking the Annuity?
Real World Example
For purposes of this paper, we have chosen to analyze the Jul 25 2008 Mega Millions drawing. We believe this Jackpot Analysis is relevant because it represents the minimum jackpot payment as defined by the rules, and is current as of this writing.
Graph MM0808a illustrates the Jackpot Offerings for the Jul 25 2008 Mega Millions drawing.
Having little other information, most winners will elect to receive the Cash Option, believing that the $7.1 million is a fair amount within the current interest rate environment.
However, this Cash Option may not be fair.
Therefore, the purpose of this paper is to provide Mega Millions players with more information about their two options. In this, we shall examine both the tax implications of each, and explain how fluctuating interest rates influence the size of the offered Cash Option, and more. By
Analyzing and Comparing the
Cash and Annuity Mega Millions Options
Cash and Annuity Mega Millions Options
we believe both players and winners will have a better understanding of the fairness of the estimated cash option being offered in any particular Mega Millions drawing.
How the Cash and Annuity are Paid
In Mega Millions, a Jackpot annuity winner receives 26 equal payments over a 25 year period. This differs from Powerball whose payments are graduated over a 29 year period. Taxes are paid yearly on receipt of each payment, meaning that all accrued interest earned remains tax free until payment is made to the winner.
Conversely, players who choose to receive the Cash Option will receive a single lump sum payment whose estimated value is stated on their web site. Taxes on this full amount is payable in the year received.
Mega Millions describes these different payment options on their page: "Differences Between Cash Value and Annuity".
Mega Millions Annuity Yearly Cashflow Payments
Because each of the Mega Millions Annuity Payments is fixed, the amount of money that the Mega Millions organization must deposit varies, depending on the: length of time until payment is made, and interest rates earned on this money. However, the payments made to the winner is always fixed. This means that players who won $12 million and elected the annuity option, would receive an 26 annual payment of $462 thousand every year.
Assuming that the prevailing interest rates are at an even 4% per year, Graph MM0808b illustrates the 26 annuity cash deposits that would be required by Mega Millions in order to meet these payments.
We have chosen the 4.0% interest rate level because this is the rate that the competing Powerball assumes its reinvestment. By using this same rate, we can reliably compare the cash values of both of these lotteries.
Note: This graph is for an $12 M annuity, but is scalable. If the annuity is $30 M, multiply payments by 2.5; if $84 M, multiply by 7; if $240 M, multiply by 20; etc.
As shown, the blue horizontal line illustrates the constant payment of $462K made to the winner. The vertical green bars illustrate the money required to be deposited. Notice that as the time increases, the amount of money Mega Millions must deposit is reduced. This is because compound interest is being earned on each deposited cashflow. When interest rates are 4.0%, Mega Millions would need $462K for the first payment; $365K for the 5th year; $289K for year 10, ... and finally $143K for the 26th and final payment. The differences between the deposited amount and the $462K payment is the interest earned.
To be fair to the players, the total the 26 deposits should equal to the Cash Value Offered at the time the tickets are being sold. Since we are assuming 4.0% as a fair interest rate, Mega Millions must aside $7.672 Million in order to make these payments of $12 M to you.
We shall define this value of $7.672 million as Par.
The Par Cash to Annuity ratio is 63.9%.
The Par Cash to Annuity ratio is 63.9%.
Jul 25 2008 Jackpot Revised
Adding the $7.672 M Par Value to our Jackpot Graph (MM0808c) provides us with a relative measure by which to judge the fairness of the $7.1 million cash option offering. As shown, the Cash Option is $0.572 million below Par. This means that those who elect the Cash Offer immediately lose $0.572 of their winnings. In terms of ratios, we are offered 59.2% verses the par 63.9%, or a 4.7% loss.
But we know for sure that if we take the Annuity, $7.672 M will be set aside for our winnings. If we take the Cash Option, we immediately lose nearly $600,000. This comes out to losing $22 thousand per year.
Fair Value of Mega Millions Cash Option at Varying Interest Rates
Both the Mega Millions organization and us recognize that interest rates vary. Because of this, the value of the cash option will move in the opposite direction of interest rate movements. This means that if interest rates go up, the cash option goes down, and vice-versa. Knowing the fair value of the cash option at various interest rate levels further will help us to judge the fairness of the Cash Option being offered.
This graph tells us that when interest rates are at 2%, Mega Millions must invest $9.472 million to fund our $12 million annuity. At 3% interest, $8.498 must be deposited for funding. And, when interest rates rise to 10%, only $4.651 needs to be invested.
Referring to this graph, we observe that the July 25 2008 Cash Option of $7.1 M equates to an interest rate environment of slightly less than 5%. Considering that interest rates have fallen substantially during January 2008 and May 2008 (from 4.25% to 2.00%) and continue to remain low, this 5% investment level appears to be rather high.
Thus, the July 25 2008 $7.1 Million Cash Option begins to appear to be rather low.
Note: This graph is for an $12 M annuity, but is scalable. If the annuity is $30 M, multiply amounts by 2.5; if $84 M, multiply by 7; if $240 M, multiply by 20; etc.
Tax Implications
Regardless which option a winner selects, taxes represent a large portion of the income. Winners are automatically moved into the highest tax bracket, and both standard and itemized deductions become limited.
Because of this, we assume that Federal Taxes will consume 35% of one's winnings.
This means that those who elect the $12 million Annuity Option will pay a total of $4.2 million to the IRS. Without paying State taxes (many states do not tax those residents who win Mega Millions),
Annuity winners keep $7.8 million
to spend and invest. One important benefit of taking the annuity is that taxes will only be paid on the amount of money given to the winner each year. All other interest being earned will remain and grow tax free until it is paid out later.
Conversely, those who decide to take the Cash Option will be taxed immediately. In the case of the July 25 2008 cash jackpot, the winner will immediately fork over $2.5 million to the IRS. This means that the cash winner will only pocket $4.6 million. Typically, Mega Millions withholds only 25% of the jackpot winnings. This means that winners will be liable for the remaining 10% when they file their taxes. Most winners do not realize this and are unhappily shocked when they learn about the additional tax consequences.
The website USAMega.com provides excellent Mega Millions Jackpot Analysis pages that summarize both the Federal and State Tax implications on the Annuity and Cash Options.
Cash Value Implied Yield Curves
Knowing that $12 M annuity winners will retain $7.8 million of their winnings after taxes, it is possible to construct the associated Implied Yield Curves that will provide the cash option winners with the same amount of money. Using this $7.8 M value as a target, the Blue Curve displays the Tax Free Rates for varying cash offerings, meaning that the earned interest is not taxed until paid. Whereas, the Green Curve indicates the Taxable Equivalent Curve. The horizontal axis indicates the cash value offering in millions. The vertical axis indicates yield rates.
Note: These Cash Jackpot values are based on a $12 M annuity, and are scalable. If the annuity is $30 M, divide the offered amount by 2.5; if $84 M, divide by 7; if $240 M, divide by 20; etc.
Assuming that this is the fair value, it will be the same amount that Mega Millions will invest for the Annuity winners. From the graph MM0808e Blue Curve, we can guesstimate that Mega Millions will invest this money at approximately 5.0%. The interest earned on the annual payments will compound tax free at this rate and will generate a total of $12 M in payments to the winner. After paying taxes, the player will get to keep the $7.8 million.
However, if the player selects the cash option, he will receive $7.1 million, pay $2.5 M in taxes, and invest the remaining $4.6 million. The Green Curve in graph MM0808e already takes the reduction of taxes into account. So, to find the taxable equivalent yield the player must earn, we locate $7.1 M on the horizontal axis, then find the point on the Green Line above it. Doing this, we find that the cash option winner must receive approximately 6.5% on the remaining $4.6 M in order to earn $7.8 million.
Evaluating the July 25 2008 Cash Offering
Considering the Federal Reserve has reduced interest rates substantially, we know that short term rates are around 2.3%, 10-year Treasuries less than 4.0%, and 30-year treasuries below 4.5%. Thus, it is impossible for Mega Millions to earn an average rate of 5.0% on the annuity deposits at this time. Therefore, we conclude that:
The $7.1 million cash offering is extremely undervalued,
and should be at least $7.7 or more million.
and should be at least $7.7 or more million.
Cash Loss per Million (Mar 14 - Aug 29 2008)
To test the correlation of the Mega Millions Cash Option Jackpot offering against actual changes in interest rates, we have constructed the Cash Loss per Annuity Million graph at right.
As shown, the graph covered the 49 drawings beginning March 14 2008 and ending August 29 2008. The magnitude of the loss is displayed on the y-axis, and ranges from $10,000 to $60,000 per annuity equivalent million dollars. The vertical Green Lines indicate when a Mega Millions Jackpot was won and was reset to the minimum $12 M. The horizontal Blue Line indicates the average loss of $30,000 per million.
During this period, the FOMC reduced the Federal Funds Target rate twice:
- Mar 18 2008 - from 3.00% to 2.25%, and
- Apr 30 2008 - from 2.25% to 2.00%.
Because the interest rates were lowered, we would expect the Ratio of the Cash Offered Jackpot to Annuity to the closer to the Par Jackpot ratio of 63.9%, thus bringing the Loss per Million closer to zero.
But in reality, the Cash offering by Mega Millions appears to be random. During the period March 18 and April 30 when Fed Funds was 2.25%, the loss spiked to $60K, then dropped to $10K. After the April 30 cut, the losses remained constant, around $30K. Afterwards, the losses grew until the June 13th jackpot win, then fell. When the jackpot was reset on July 25th, the loss unexpectedly jumped to $47 K. Again in this cycle, as the Annuity jackpot has risen, the cash option loss has fallen to only $20 K per million.
Since players and winners had no basis to evaluate the fairness of the cash prize offering, complete trust was placed in the Mega Millions estimate, which appears to be arbitrary, and not really correlated to actual interest rates. Based on all of this, we believe that the:
Mega Millions Annuity Offer is Best!
Summary
To summarize, Mega Millions winners who elect to receive the Cash Option are usually penalized because: the Cash Option Value is under estimated; interest rates are typically lower than that offered by the Annuity; and, taxes erode the both the cash payment and interest earned.
Conversely, Mega Millions players who win $12M and elect to receive the Annuity payments will retain $7.8 million in cash, and will pay $4.2 million in taxes.
This equates to approximately $42.3 thousand dollars per year. This is a lot of money.
Note: All amounts shown are based on a $12 M annuity at 4% interest. These values are scalable. Thus, if the annuity is $30 M, multiply amounts by 2.5; if $84 M, multiply by 7; if $240 M, multiply by 20; etc.
Conclusion
In this discussion, we have: illustrated how the Mega Millions Annuity payments are made; identified the fair cash value Par value of $7.672 million; described the fair cash jackpot offerings at varying interest rates; created the non-taxable and taxable implied break-even yield curves; shown the historical cash loss per million; and summarized the breakdowns of money retained, taxes paid, and money lost.
By focusing on the July 25 2008 cash and annuity jackpot offerings of $7.1 M and $12 M, we have concluded that winners in this drawing are far better off by receiving the Annuity Payments instead of the Cash Option.
Lastly, our advice with regard to this Mega Millions drawing (and most likely others) is to:
Take the Annuity,
You'll have alot More Money
Unless things change.
And remember, if you check the Annuity Option when you buy your tickets, you can change your mind and take the Cash Option (depending in which state you purchase the ticket). Those originally selecting the Cash Option cannot reverse that decision. You'll have alot More Money
Unless things change.
Learn More
We have not found many sites that provide detailed Mega Millions Jackpot information. However, you can learn more by visiting the following:
- Mega Millions Game Rules (from NJ Lottery)
- USAMega.com - Mega Millions Frequently Asked Questions
- What to do when you win the lottery
- CASH VS.ANNUITY: WHICH ONE IS THE BEST ONE TO TAKE IF I WIN?
Labels:
annuity,
invest,
lottery,
mathematics,
mega millions,
win
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)